Wednesday, February 29, 2012

SHE COULD HAVE HAD IT ALL


THEME: TAKING A LEAP
All growth is a leap in the dark, a spontaneous unpremeditated act without benefit of experience. ~ Henry Miller


I get temporarily popular every time a celebrity overdoses, suicides, or runs into some sort of ditch. Given my therapy background, people want to hear my attempt to explain such behavior. With Whitney Houston’s death, the question seems to be a three-parter: Why couldn’t she 1) kick that Bobby Brown aside, 2) get clean and sober and stay that way, and 3) get back to singing like she was supposed to?
There is an angry question lurking just below: How could she have a gift like that voice and squander it? 
As I sit here I contend with dueling earworms.  With Whitney singing, “I will always love you…” and Adele belting, “We could have had it all…” it’s hard to think. But I’ll take a crack at it.
I will stipulate that the behavior of an addict is incomprehensible to the normal bystander. Broken promises, lies, financial ruin, lost jobs, fractured relationships, and all the rest render the addict irresponsible, weak, pathetic, and stupid in the eyes of others. Their behavior looks and feels intentional.
The people who care about them eventually need to take a step back to save their own sanity. Into that space, especially with celebrities, others who don’t actually care about them step in ready to take part. Plus, anyone in the vicinity who shares their affliction helps to keep it going. It is a powerful system bent on its own continuation, and might help explain Bobby Brown’s continued presence in Whitney’s life. Whoever sent him away from the memorial service at least made a point.
But how does the addiction take a death grip on an otherwise capable, even exceptional, person like Whitney?
I have a laundry list of explanations in my head, cobbled together from years of observing and theorizing. Pick your favorites.
*One theory says that all the addict wants to do is chase the exquisite pleasure of his or her first time. Maybe, research suggests, the pleasure that an addict gets from using his substance is on a whole different level than most people would experience. The problem is that the pleasure is never to be found again.
*Addicts describe their disordered thinking as if they are constantly spinning, which only allows them to encounter reality occasionally on a brief fly-by.
*Some describe finding that the first time they ever felt normal was during their first use. Later, many can feel normal only while under the influence. Worse, as they become physically addicted, to not use becomes painful due to withdrawal symptoms. It is no longer a matter of pleasure, but pain.
*Once life becomes too painful to face, drugs and alcohol provide escape. Pain can originate with losses, or failed expectations, or runaway expectations, or the depressive effects of the chemicals, or a hundred other sources. Once an addict finds his way to oblivion, it becomes a regular destination.
*Addiction is a disease that takes charge over the body, mind, and spirit. It makes the decisions, dictates the feelings, and drives the behavior.  The individual is no longer a person with free will, but more like a host to an aggressive parasite.
*What goes on is an expression of cellular changes, the interaction between brain chemicals and receptors, that expresses itself in egregious behavior.
*Outside influences of people, places and things can start things up, keep the process going, or encourage relapse. Bobby Brown and the music industry come to mind.
*The individual hasn’t done enough “research” yet to become convinced that the problem is unmanageable and that therefore entering recovery is necessary. Denial slips into and out of place. The lucky ones hit bottom in time.
*Finally, it is indisputable that the addict misses a lot, being under the influence and possibly in a blackout for many crucial experiences. What they can’t remember is not part of their experience, and therefore does not motivate them toward change.
Those ideas and theories form a mudball of cause and effect. They may all be true, or not. They certainly make clear that there is no one simple answer.
If it’s hard for me to understand, it’s even more incomprehensible to the addict. And no one is more disappointed in the addict than he or she is. They wish for normalcy. But achieving it in the face of addiction is a big order. It requires large doses of knowledge, support, and hope. The longer the track record of failure, the less accessible those become.
Meanwhile, the addiction offers its own gifts: immediate pain relief, oblivion, escape. Whether the addiction seeks to chase the sublime or escape the intolerable, it’s an ironic struggle. While the body and mind duke it out in a private battle, it cannot be won without outside help, practical or spiritual, or both. How to make that happen remains a mystery for many.
Maybe we should confine ourselves to other question: Do we have gifts we are squandering? At least we can do something about that.

CBH 02/11